A burger is a simple yet classic staple on the American food menu. The concept is simple – burger patty sandwiched between two buns, topped with cheese, lettuce, pickles, mayo or whatever your heart desires. But the simplicity allows for mouthwatering possibilities with unique twists – think peanut butter or even an egg.
We worked with our friends at Yelp Indy to find the top places for a burger in Hamilton County. Did your favorite make the list? Read on to find out.
Methodology: This is an all-time list of the top 10 restaurants with burgers in Hamilton County according to Yelp. We identified businesses in the restaurant category that mentioned burgers in reviews and are not part of a national chain, then ranked those spots using a number of factors including the total volume and ratings of reviews. This list was updated in January 2024.
12901 Old Meridian St., Carmel
BRU features gourmet chef burgers using locally-sourced meats and vegetables. You can’t go wrong with the namesake Bru Burger with taleggio cheese, bacon, tomato jam, caramelized onion, chopped lettuce and mayo. Other popular burgers include the Bourbon Burger with peppercorn-bourbon glaze, Provençal with herbed goat cheese, and Melt Your Face with all things habanero and jalapeño.
“Solid burger choice and fast service. Burgers are juicy and stacked nicely. Onion rings are cooked prior to fryer, so they are always tender and cut with each bite…delicious. Recommend the Taxi Bourbon Sour drink. Lovely concoction.” – Yelper Rod M.
650 W. Carmel Dr., Carmel
Located in Carmel, this restaurant serves gourmet cooked-to-serve wagyu burgers. Offering halal-certified and gluten-free options, including grilled or breaded chicken, lamb, salmon, falafel, turkey and impossible patties.
“Flight burger is so yummy! They have a lot of options of mix and match slides and burgers, as well as loaded fries and other fun appetizers. It’s a fast option to get a slider or burger craving in.” – Yelper Zuha A.
210 W. Main St., Carmel
As the name suggests, burgers are Bub’s specialty – with ice cream for dessert, of course. The burgers here are hand-pattied and served on locally baked (and toasted) buns. Challenge yourself to eat the infamous “Big Ugly®” One Pound burger and you can get your picture on the wall of fame. For smaller appetites, there’s the “Not So Ugly®” Half Pound, “Settle for Less Ugly®” Quarter Pound and even elk burgers.
“You can never go wrong with having dinner at Bub’s! Elk is fantastic, as is the chili! Atmosphere is inviting and the place is clean. The service is really good and did I mention, the food is fricken awesome! If you haven’t tried it, you are missing out.” – Yelper Jerry H.
101 N. 10th St., Noblesville
This is the sister business of Grindstone on the Monon, located near the Historic Noblesville Square. The look and feel of the restaurants are similar, but not quite identical. At Grindstone Public House, try the Clancy’s Topper – a double-stacked burger with American cheese, house tartar sauce and double-decker sesame seed bun.
“Grindstone has a nice atmosphere that feels upscale without being stuffy. They have a good drinks menu with lots of variety. They have exceptional food and a reasonable price. The service is often quite good as well. Overall, I think this is a great restaurant that you should check out if you’re in the area for brunch, dinner, or drinks!” – Yelper Samuel L.
11671 Lantern Rd., Fishers
Located in the Nickel Plate District in Fishers, this popular brewery serves craft brews and tasty burgers.
“This is one of the best Indy area restaurants I’ve had and probably my favorite. Between the food, beer and service, Four Day Ray is a must go.” – Yelper Heather B.
14300 Mundy Dr., #1300, Noblesville
Foodies can’t get enough of Best Bet, which is also on the list of Yelp’s best places for breakfast and lunch in Hamilton County. For a taste of breakfast and lunch, try the Donnie burger, topped with Ava taters, two eggs, American cheese and two slices of bacon. If you like spice, try the Route 66 burger made with Cajun spices and swiss cheese.
“The burgers here are incredible! Burger comes with a deviled egg and small portion of baked beans. You should really give this place a try!” – Yelper Rob W.
550 E. 96th St., Indianapolis
Punch Burger was started by two guys in Indiana looking for a great burger and beer for a great price. All our beef is sourced from Midwestern farmers with no added hormones or antibiotics.
“This was exactly what we are looking for. A standard burger that was perfectly prepared and Juicy with lettuce cheese tomato onion mayo and ketchup.” – Yelper David H.
1200 S. Rangeline Rd., Ste. 100, Carmel
Started by a husband who is a New England culinary institute-trained chef and a wife who is a finance professional, 101 Beer Kitchen offers elevated comfort food in a charming and comfortable style.
“If I was making a list oof my top 10 restaurants, I think 101 Beer Kitchen would make the list. This place is fantastic! I love their rotating seasonal menu and the whole ambiance of the restaurant. Fresh ingredients and a menu that will please almost any palette.” – Yelper Hannah F.
10 W. Jackson St., Cicero
[restaurant description] Located on the corner street of Cicero, 10 West is a gem. Try the culinary creations of Chef Bill Wampler and be sure to check out The Cellar, a speakeasy-like environment located in the basement.
“Every time we go to 10 West in Cicero we wonder why we don’t eat here more often!…Service is outstanding; food is always VERY good and decently priced; drinks are generous.” – Yelper Cathy P.
This family-friendly restaurant in Fishers is heroes-themed, like the name suggests, honoring local firemen to superheroes and everyone in between. As for the burgers, CR Heroes offers options like the Jalapeño Beer Cheeseburger, Blackened & Bleu burger, Don’t Go Bacon My Heart and more.
“I had a burger the size of my head and it was so delicious. the meat was cooked perfectly and it was put together so yummily.” – Yelper Nina O.
For more information on new restaurants in Hamilton County, be sure to follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram to see what’s happening in #VisitHC.
