Males’s KEEN Targhee IV WP Assessment

Bottom Line

The KEEN Targhee IV WPs are a crowd-pleaser when it comes to traction, a roomy toe box, a secure lacing system, and overall stability. These classic leather kicks are perfect for rugged, technical backcountry conditions and provide some of the best waterproofing of any of the top men’s hiking shoes we tested, making them ideal for wet trails and cooler weather. When snow is lingering, the weather forecast looks iffy, or we’re hiking in the shoulder seasons, the Targhee IVs are one of the first hiking shoes we reach for.

However, they are heavier than some alternatives, have stiff soles, and require a longer break-in period. Our team at CleverHiker has hiked in the Targhee IVs from the Colorado backcountry in February to the Arizona desert in November, and they’ve proved to be durable and supportive, though their bulk and leather construction can cause them to run hot in warm conditions. These shoes are best suited for hikers seeking durable, comfortable, and stable footwear for challenging trails.

Comfort

The KEEN Targhee IV WP hiking shoes are comfortable no matter what your foot shape or size. We love their durable, pliable leather uppers, which mold to your feet over time to provide a fit like a glove, and the secure lacing system helps achieve a snug fit to prevent any unnecessary sliding or movement inside the shoe. The Targhees also feature a wide toe box so your toes can move naturally and unrestricted, and you’ll be able to bend your forefoot easily on steep ascents and technical terrain to reduce fatigue on long hikes.

Their generously cushioned insoles and midsoles offer plenty of support and absorb shock on tough trails. And, an oversized, protective toe cap and burly heel cup keep your feet secure and safe from potential hazards on trail to keep you feeling comfortable during the long haul.

Unfortunately, the leather construction requires a longer break-in period, so you’ll need to budget around 20-25 miles to soften the shoes and reach maximum comfort. The Targhees are also on the bulkier and heavier side, which makes them exceptionally durable, but the added weight can feel cumbersome on longer treks. Although they’re waterproof, that means the leather uppers are less breathable, leading to potential overheating in warm weather and humid conditions, so you’ll want to save these for cooler hikes below 75°F.

Traction

If you’re looking for seriously sticky traction, the KEEN Targhee IVs are an awesome choice. Their multi-directional lug pattern reliably grips on almost any dry surface you’ll encounter on trail, including gravel, dirt, and rocks. The lugs, although shallow and wide, feel stable and durable, and a wide outsole will make you feel confident and reduce the risk of slips and falls in mixed trail conditions.

On the downside, the Targhee IV’s traction excels in dry, rocky, and varied terrains but falls short in consistently wet environments. We find the chunky lug pattern is less effective on wet or slippery surfaces, making them feel less reliable in rainy conditions or on slick roots and rocks.

Weight

Despite their slightly bulky aesthetic, the KEEN Targhee IV WP hiking shoes are impressively light. They strike a great balance compared to the hiking shoes we’ve tested, coming in at one pound, eight ounces for a pair. This weight makes them a mid-range shoe in our lineup, so they’re a great option for shorter hikes for people who prioritize durability and support over ultralight construction.

The reason they’re a bit heavier is their build: the Targhees feature bombproof leather uppers and robust outsoles made from a durable rubber composite, which offers excellent protection and stability on rugged trails. If you prioritize longevity and comfort in your footwear, this weight is a solid compromise.

However, compared to lighter shoes, the Targhee IVs can feel heavy during extended hikes, and the additional weight will contribute to faster fatigue over long distances as well as steep ascents and descents. If you’re looking for featherlight footwear for speed or reduced strain on joints and muscles, you may want to consider lighter shoes or trail runners instead.

Durability

These shoes are the best of the best when it comes to durability. Gear analyst Ian Krammer has put over 250 miles on his Targhees in remote backcountry routes high in the Colorado Rockies, and they look as sharp and perform as strong as they did at mile 20. With sturdy all-leather uppers that offer robust protection against abrasions, rocks, and other trail hazards, complemented by double-stitched panels along the outsoles, the Targhees are among the most durable and longest-lasting footwear we’ve tested.

We’ve also found the stiff outsole and lugs are slow to wear down and the rubber composite performs admirably even after dozens of rocky trails and boulder field crossings. And, since the toe cap is fused to the shoe – not glued – the rubber doesn’t delaminate over time, and will easily endure hundreds of miles in brutal backcountry environments kicking rocks, bashing through the forest, and navigating talus.

The downside of burly leather uppers is they require a bit more care, including waterproof treatment and cleaning, versus synthetic textiles or all-mesh options. And, the leather upper combined with a slightly stiffer sole means these shoes have a longer lifespan than most hiking shoes we’ve tested – up to 500-600 miles – but they can be a bit slow to break in, and aren’t as breathable or quick-drying as synthetic options.

Weather Resistance

For folks hiking in cool, wet, and unexpected weather conditions in the fall, spring, and even mild winter conditions, the KEEN Targhee IVs are a no-brainer. Their waterproof construction and leather uppers effectively keep water out whether it’s rain, puddles, or stream crossings, so your feet will stay bone dry and comfortable on the trail. The leather uppers, combined with generous padding, also mean they will keep your feet feeling warm when the temperatures are cooler. The shoes’ ability to repel moisture and retain a bit of warmth makes them über versatile across different seasons and terrain.

The trade-off is these shoes are not very breathable, so they aren’t our favorites in hot summer weather. The waterproof membrane restricts airflow, which can lead to sweaty feet and the potential for blisters and hot spots when temperatures are above 75°F, you’re hiking in humid climates, or heating up during an intense hike.

Should You Buy the Keen Targhee IV WP?

The KEEN Targhee IV is perfect for hikers who want a dependable, roomy, and durable shoe for challenging and soggy backcountry conditions. With excellent traction, a secure lacing system, and a roomy toe box, these shoes offer unparalleled comfort and stability for long hikes in rain, snow, and mud. They excel on gnarly trails, cooler weather, and shorter adventures, making them a great choice for hikers who prioritize durability and support over lightweight flexibility. 

However, their heavier weight and longer break-in period may not suit folks seeking ultra-lightweight or highly breathable footwear. The waterproofing is very effective, but can easily lead to overheating in warmer conditions. If you need a long-lasting, supportive shoe for rugged terrain and cooler climates, the KEEN Targhee IV is a top pick.

What Other Hiking Shoes Should You Consider?

Merrell Moab 3 Review: The Merrell Moab is a great alternative with its similarly classic aesthetic, dependable traction, and roomy fit. However, the Moabs offer better breathability in both the waterproof and non-waterproof versions, making them suitable for warmer climates, and they offer a more flexible midsole.

HOKA Anacapa 2 Low GTX Review: The HOKA Anacapa shares the Targhee IV’s excellent support and waterproofing. However, this is the perfect shoe to consider if you want a lighter pair with thicker foam in the midsole, with a much cushier and responsive ride for long-distance hikes and rocky trails.

La Sportiva Spire GTX Review: The La Sportiva Spire GTX also offers superb traction and durability akin to the Targhee IV. However, it stands out with a Gore-Tex liner, lower stack height, and more modern aesthetic that performs like a hiking boot but looks like a hiking shoe.