Bottom Line
The Merrell Moab 3s are an excellent budget option and are one of our favorites in our guide to the best hiking shoes for women thanks to their solid comfort and durability. We’ve put them to the test on trails and found they excel in providing a cushioned, supportive feel, though they’re a bit bulky for long treks. Their leather and mesh upper balances durability and breathability, and while there’s a waterproof version, we usually prefer the non-waterproof model for its quicker drying and better breathability.
Tested across rugged terrain in Lake Tahoe, Donner Pass, and sections of the PCT, these shoes offer excellent cushioning and impact protection. They performed better on solid rock and compact dirt than on loose, rocky trails.
We appreciate the Moab 3s’ ample traction and stability, which are handy on various terrains. They might feel stiff and heavy, but their straightforward comfort and supportive fit make them ideal for day hikes and shorter adventures. They’re not the flashiest or lightest, but for those seeking a reliable shoe that doesn’t empty the bank tank, the Moabs are a solid choice.
Quick Specs
Pros
- Lightweight
- Above-average comfort
- No break-in needed
- Less Expensive
Cons
- Not as durable as some
- Not supportive enough for heavy loads
Comfort
The Moab 3 enhances comfort with a softer insole and additional midsole cushioning, making it more comfortable right out of the box. Previous models required more break-in time, but we found the Merrell Moab 3s to be comfortable right from the trailhead. Their plush midsole and soft leather/mesh upper required almost no break-in period. However, the sizing was quite large, and they were bulky on the foot compared to other out-of-the-box favorites.
The cushioning is exceptional, offering solid protection from rough terrain while keeping our feet comfortable throughout long hikes. However, the added cushioning made us feel slightly higher off the ground, which took some time to get used to, especially on uneven surfaces. It felt like they may make rolling an ankle more likely, which isn’t a feeling anyone wants. The Moab 3 offers improved support with a firmer insole and a more stable arch, which are great for carrying heavier loads. Many find the Moab 3 provides better stability than other shoes with the firm Kinetic Fit insole and molded nylon arch. Still, the low-cut design left us wishing for better ankle support on steeper sections.
Traction
The Vibram TC5+ outsole gave solid grip on flat, dry trails and smooth rocks, but struggled in more challenging conditions. Mud and loose gravel proved tricky as the shallow lugs clogged up easily, reducing the shoe’s effectiveness in maintaining grip. For general hiking, the traction is sufficient, but for more technical or off-trail adventures, we might reach for a shoe with a more aggressive lug pattern.
Weight
At over two pounds per pair, the weight of the Moab 3s is noticeable on longer hikes. This really comes down to personal preference and how a shoe’s weight adds to your foot placement confidence on mixed terrain. To us, they felt bulky on our feet, a little bogged down during full-day hikes. On the contrary, some hikers feel a heavier hiker provides a solid, protective feel that gives them the confidence and security to take on longer, rugged treks.
Durability
While the materials used are similar, the construction on the Moab 3 feels slightly more robust than previous iterations. However, like previous versions, durability at the seams could still be a concern after extended use and abrasive terrain. The Moab 3s held up well under various conditions, and we appreciated the balance of leather and mesh in the upper. While the suede showed some wear after a few hikes, the overall construction felt sturdy, and we experienced no major durability issues.
Weather Resistance
The Moab 3s performed decently in light rain and shallow water crossings, keeping our feet mostly dry and comfortable. However, after sustained exposure to wet conditions, the fabric will allow water through and take more time to dry out, perhaps due to the extra cushioning and leather upper.
Should You Buy the Merrell Moab 3?
The Merrell Moab 3s are ideal for hikers seeking a reliable, budget-friendly shoe with strong support and comfort. They’re perfect for day hikers or those who want the protection of a hiking boot without the restrictive high collar. The combination of leather and mesh in the upper offers a solid mix of durability and breathability, making them great for general trail use. However, the heavier design and bulky feel may not suit those planning long-distance treks or more technical terrain. They’re not ideal for extended exposure to wet conditions, as they are slow to dry. Still, the Moab 3s are an excellent choice for casual hikers and outdoor pursuits who prioritize cushioning and durability over lightweight agility.
What Other Women’s Hiking Shoes Should You Consider?
If the Merrell Moab 3s don’t quite fit your needs, consider these other options:
La Sportiva Spire GTX: The La Sportiva Spire GTX for a more technical and demanding trail experience. The Spires offer excellent traction and stability, making them ideal for challenging terrain or hikers carrying heavy packs.
KEEN Targhee IV WPs: If you’re looking for a durable, long-lasting shoe with a locked-in fit and wide toe box, the KEEN Targhee IV WPs are a great alternative, especially for those seeking extra room and comfort on shorter hikes.
Oboz Sawtooth X WP: For backpackers prioritizing arch support and handling heavy loads, the Oboz Sawtooth X WP stands out with its premium insoles and durable design, perfect for rough terrain and big adventures.
