The Greatest Highway Bike Saddles of 2024

When it comes to comfort, your road bike saddle is arguably the most critical contact point on your bike. When road cycling, we spend lots of time sitting on our saddles, so finding the right one for riding style, body position, and, most importantly, one that fits you properly is of the utmost importance.

By positioning and supporting the pelvis — the control center of the pedal stroke — the saddle influences the movement and comfort of the entire body, from the knees all the way up to the neck and shoulders. Finding the ideal saddle shape can be a process of trial and error, but by reading this guide, we hope you can hone in on suitable options and find your ideal saddle more easily.

We gathered 14 road bike saddles, from well-established industry leaders to lesser-known innovators, and tested them each for several weeks of daily riding. Review author Bennett Shane personally tested each saddle in this buyer’s guide, swapping between models for months while putting in miles and assessing factors like design, shape, comfort, pressure relief, and weight.

Our top picks are listed below along with the best of the rest that are all worthy options to consider. To view the specs of the models we tested at a glance, check out our handy comparison chart. If you need help deciding what’s right for you, our comprehensive buying advice is a great place to start, and our Price & Value section may be helpful when determining how much to spend.

Editor’s Note: This guide originally appeared on our sister site, Bikerumor.com, and was first published here on August TKTK, 2024. At the same time, we added the gravel and rough road friendly Ergon SR Allroad Pro Core Men to our selection and added more information to our Price & Value section that may be helpful when choosing the right road bike saddle.

The Best Road Bike Saddles of 2024

Road Bike Saddle Comparison Chart

How We Tested the Best Road Bike Saddles

At GearJunkie, we take pride in testing, reviewing, and reporting on the best outdoor gear. Our crew of passionate outdoors people includes numerous hardcore cyclists who spend lots of time on the bike, whether testing new bikes, components, accessories, or apparel, training for the next race, or riding just for the fun of it. All that time spent in the saddle has taught us the importance of having the right tools for the job, from finding the best road bike tires to getting the right saddle so we can be comfortable for hours on end. We also know just how tough it can be to find the perfect one.

For our road bike saddle buyer’s guide, we tapped frequent contributor and road cycling expert Bennett Shane to test and compare the 14 models included in this review. Bennett has been road cycling for over two decades and, in that time, has spanned the spectrum of riding disciplines. Though he hasn’t lined up for a race in a few years, he spent quite a bit of time rubbing elbows in crits and pelotons. These days he prefers to put in big miles on epic rides throughout the Pacific Northwest near his home base near Portland, OR.

On top of his cycling experience, Bennett spent years working in the cycling industry for several prominent brands. This experience has given him unique insight into the product lifecycle as well as the design, materials, and construction of products spanning from apparel to components. When considered together, his experience in the industry and as a rider/consumer gives him an understanding of products from the inside out, and he has developed a keen ability to discern the performance differences in the products he tests. Bennett has applied his testing expertise to several other categories, including protective road bike helmets, the best road bike shoes, and cycling bib shorts.

After researching the best and most popular road bike saddles on the market, we rounded up 14 models for side-by-side testing and comparison. After weighing each model for comparison to the manufacturer’s specs, they were mounted up on Bennett’s small fleet of boutique road bikes and taken for numerous rides to get a feel for their shape, comfort, padding, anatomical relief, and, most importantly, how they stack up against each other. After thousands of miles of testing, we honed in our favorite models and those that excel in specific ways compared to the rest.

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose a Road Bike Saddle

A good road bike saddle is critical for your comfort on the bike. With so many models, sizes, materials, and designs to choose from, finding the right saddle isn’t the most straightforward thing in the world. There’s a lot to consider when choosing a new saddle, so here we break down the most important factors to help you make a more informed purchase decision.

What Type of Riding Do You Do?

The type of riding you do, and most importantly, your body position while riding, plays a major role in the saddle that will work best for you. Racers and aggressive riders tend to lean forward more, which results in more forward pelvic rotation. Often, riders in these powerful positions tend to prefer saddles with short lengths, flat side-to-side profiles, flat tip-to-tail profiles, and effective anatomical relief in the form of a cutout or channel.

Riders who ride more casually or simply prefer a more relaxed body position for endurance riding may benefit from a somewhat rounded side-to-side profile and a slightly cradled tip-to-tail profile that provides more support. That said, there are no hard and fast rules, and the saddle that works best for you is the one that fits you well and provides long-term comfort.

Width and Sizing

Our bodies are all different, so finding the correct saddle width to suit your anatomy is one of the most important things you can do for comfort. Many people don’t realize that road bike saddles come in varying widths to accommodate different-sized and shaped bodies to get an ideal fit. The distance between our sit bones, in particular, is very important to consider as that is where the majority of our weight rests while seated.

A saddle that is too narrow doesn’t provide enough support for the sit bones and can result in excessive pressure on the perineum or pubic bone arch and sensitive soft tissues. Likewise, a saddle that is too wide can cause discomfort by pushing outward on the hips or digging into your inner thighs and negatively impacting the pedal stroke.

Saddles range in width from around 125 mm up to 160 mm, generally speaking. Many saddles, like the Bontrager Verse Comp, for example, are offered in several different width options across this spectrum, while others are available in only a single width. While many riders associate narrower sizes with reduced friction, an appropriately sized saddle can actually reduce friction and many other issues by promoting greater pelvic stability.

Thankfully, you don’t have to guess your ideal saddle width. Most bike shops offer some type of measurement of the sit bones, which will tell you which saddle width is ideal for your anatomy. It is also possible to take this measurement at home, and you can easily find instructions on how to do so online. Many shops also have test saddles, so you can try them before you buy to make sure they work for you. Several brands also offer comfort guarantees, so you can try a saddle risk-free and send it back if it isn’t the right fit.

Anatomical Relief

While road riding, we spend lots of time seated and pedaling, with most of our weight resting on and around relatively sensitive parts of our anatomy. Almost every saddle being developed now will feature a central cutout or pressure relief channel of some sort. These cutouts or channels are intended to take pressure off of the perineal area which can help to increase comfort, maintain blood flow, and reduce the chances of numbness, irritation, and other issues that may arise.

The idea is pretty simple, but the execution varies greatly from brand to brand and saddle to saddle. Some cutouts feel like little more than decoration, while others deliver legitimate pressure relief hour after hour of riding. Along with a good, well-fitting saddle, a quality pair of cycling bib shorts is an essential piece of kit that can enhance comfort over the course of your rides.

Saddle Profile: Side to Side

A saddle’s profile — the shape of the saddle from side to side across its widest part — is a key factor in comfort. Much like the width of a saddle, different profile shapes, typically flat or curved, may work better with people’s unique anatomies and different riding styles. Profiles vary from brand to brand and model to model, and some saddles, like the PRO Stealth Team, are even offered in both a regular and a curved version.

Traditionally, saddle profiles were more rounded, as it was thought that a gradually curving profile would be more accommodating to the sensitive tissue around the pelvis. While this may still work for some riders, profiles have trended flatter in recent times. Flatter profiles promise to enhance lateral stability of the pelvis, which in turn takes pressure off the lower back and encourages activation of the gluteal muscles during the pedal stroke. Another important benefit of a flat profile saddle is that it allows for more effective cutout designs. Cutouts, in combination with a flat profile, remove significant pressure from soft tissue and encourage a more even distribution of pressure across a wider section of the pelvis and surrounding muscles and soft tissue.

Also, it is important to bear in mind that a saddle’s profile can play a role in the effective width and where your sit bones rest on the saddle. A saddle that has a more rounded profile will effectively be narrower than its measured total width, while a flatter profile will be much closer to the actual width.

Saddle Profile: Tip to Tail

Another factor to consider is the profile of a saddle from tip to tail. For the most part, saddles are either fairly flat or have a slightly cradled shape. In general, a flat tip-to-tail profile is better suited to more aggressive, powerful, or aerodynamic riding positions with more forward pelvic rotation. Racers, powerful riders, and those who tend to move around the saddle typically gravitate towards a saddle with a flat profile.

Saddles with a cradled profile typically lend themselves better to more neutral or relaxed body positions with less forward pelvic rotation. If you mostly ride from the hoods or the tops or go on long endurance rides, a saddle with a slightly cradled tip-to-tail profile may be the best option for comfort and support. An example of a cradled saddle is the Selle SMP Dynamic which has a relatively dramatic curved shape that locks the rider into the sweet spot for static seated pedaling.

Rail Material

Saddles are often offered in several versions, with one of the main differentiators being the material used for the rails. Rail material plays a large role in overall saddle weight and price with lighter and more exotic materials commanding a higher price. The most common types of rails are steel, Chromoly, titanium, and carbon fiber (in order from heaviest/least expensive to lightest/most expensive). As an example, the Ergon SR Allroad Core comes in three variants. The Core Pro ($160) has TiNox rails, the Core Carbon ($200) has carbon rails, and the Core Comp ($140) has CroMo rails.

Another factor to consider with rail materials is their size. Most metal rails are round and have standard 7 x 7 mm dimensions that will work on virtually any seatpost. Carbon fiber rails allow saddles to cut upwards of 100 grams of weight but usually have 7 x 9 mm rails. Carbon fiber rails may not be compatible with all seatpost clamps (or saddle bags, for that matter), or you may need to get a special adapter to make them fit.

If purchasing a saddle with carbon fiber rails, we recommend making sure that your seatpost is compatible. Carbon rails can also make saddles feel stiffer, which may or may not be desirable. Titanium rails achieve decent weight savings compared to chromoly or steel rails, will work on virtually any seatpost, and tend to give the saddle a bit more forgiving feel than carbon fiber rails.

3D Printing

3D printed saddles represent a significant step forward in saddle technology by shifting away from traditional design, which sandwiches foam between a plastic or carbon fiber base and a synthetic cover. Instead of bonding several layers, 3D-printed saddles are made of a latticework of liquid polymer that flexes precisely to the shape and movement of each rider’s unique anatomy and pedaling motion.

Not surprisingly, two 3D-printed saddles received top honors among our test group, the Specialized Power Pro with Mirror and the Fizik Vento Argo 00 Adaptive. 3D-printed saddles are examples of true innovation in the cycling industry, and while they are more expensive, we feel they are worth the investment. In addition to the two models we tested, there are a number of other 3D-printed models from Specialized, Fizik, Selle Italia, and others.

Adjusting Your Saddle

Some fine-tuning of saddle position is almost always necessary to achieve the proper position and optimize comfort for your anatomy and riding style. Adjustments include tilting the nose up and down, sliding the saddle fore and aft (within the adjustment range of the rails), and adjusting the height by telescoping the seatpost in the bike frame.

A great place to start is with the saddle clamped in the middle of its rails, and perfectly level, then make adjustments as needed. You can use a spirit level or eyeball it with a ruler. Keep in mind that not all saddles have the same amount of stack (the vertical distance between the rails and the top of the saddle), so if you change saddles, you may also need to adjust the saddle height slightly. If you’re unsure of how to adjust your bike saddle, a professional bike fit can be a great way to dial everything in on your ride.

Women’s Saddles

All but one of the saddles we tested are unisex and are used by both male and female riders. There are a number of women-specific saddles on the market, however, that are designed to work better for female riders. While many female riders get along fine with the dimensions, shapes, and profiles of unisex saddles, some ladies may benefit from a women-specific model. While they look essentially the same as unisex models, many women-specific saddles are offered in wider widths to accommodate wider sit bones, and some may also have larger cutouts to enhance comfort for the female anatomy.

Price & Value

The cost of road bike saddles varies wildly from less than $60 all the way up to $400 or more. With such a huge range of prices, it’s fair to wonder what you get by spending more. Regardless of price, the most important thing is to get a saddle that fits your anatomy and suits your style of riding.

Budget

Road bike saddles that cost around $100 or less are generally considered to be in the budget category. While the general shapes and comfort are about the same as their more expensive counterparts, budget-oriented saddles are typically made from less exotic materials and weigh a bit more. You won’t see much carbon fiber in this price range. Instead, most brands use steel or chromoly for rails and plastic for the shells. While they might feel roughly the same in use, you typically trade money saved for weight gained.

A good example is the Bontrager Verse Comp which retails for $100 and provides a nearly identical level of comfort to the $315 Trek RSL, although it weighs 140 g more. It’s still a great saddle, regardless. And, if you’re operating on an even tighter budget, the Ritchey Comp Cabrillo gets the job done for $60. So, unless weight is your highest priority, you don’t need to shell out the big bucks for the fanciest models on the market.

Mid-Tier

As we climb in price, mid-tier road bike saddles occupy the $150 to $250 range. Here we start to see fancier materials like titanium and carbon fiber rails, carbon or composite shells and designs catering to more specific riding styles and needs. Race-specific saddles like the PRO Stealth Team ($220), for example, are geared towards high-intensity riding and a more aggressive body position.

Other saddles in this price range bring unique shock-absorbing technology into the equation, like the Ergon SR Allroad Core Pro Men ($160). By using a unique material, this saddle does wonders to dampen vibration while remaining supportive and stable under hard pedaling efforts.

Premium

Spending top dollar — $250 and up — on a saddle typically gets you fancier materials like carbon fiber, more advanced construction methods like 3D printing, and typically a significant reduction in weight compared to the least expensive options. Here, we find the latest technology in saddles, like the Fizik Vento Argo 00 Adaptive ($400) and the Specialized Power Pro with Mirror ($325), both of which are 3D printed. Other times, it’s all about the weight, as is the case with the Trek RSL ($315), which weighs 140 g less than its less expensive sibling, the Bontrager Verse Comp.

Frequently Asked Questions