The Greatest Windshield Wipers of 2024

How We Tested Windshield Wipers

Living just north of the Rainy City, lead tester Nick Belcaster sees enough annual liquid precip to necessitate not only annual wiper blade replacement but has even swapped out a wiper motor or two from over-use. Stealing away across the West has put him atop some mountain passes at exactly the wrong moment, and he has both cheered and cursed his wiper blades, depending on their condition. 

We took a scientific approach to our wiper blade testing, aiming to distill out the marketing fluff and get some solid data through a reliable, replicateable test. This took the form of our trusty Toyota Tacoma, a few carefully aimed sprinklers, a slow-motion camera, and an audio recorder.

Each wiper was run at the same speed with the same amount of water, and the performance was recorded — then compared to suss out which blades moved the most amount of water, and which did this the quietest. For blades that required a wipe-on silicone treatment, we cleaned the windshield between tests to ensure a sterile test bed and accurate results.

We also paid close attention to the installation and removal process (and we got pretty dang good at both). Wipers often use a number of adapters to connect, and we challenged multiple testers to affix these wipers without reading the instructions. After a few nipped fingers and a few more curses, we had a good idea of the work it took to get each wiper set up.

Aside from our stationary testing, we also, of course, hit the road, driving through deluges on the Olympic Peninsula, snow storms in British Columbia, and more than a few mud holes on our way out to the perfect campsite. This frequent blade changing also gave us ample experience in learning which blades go on the easiest, and which should have come with an installation manual.

And finally, we are constantly testing the durability and longevity of these wiper blades, running them full-time on our rigs and using them until failure. Our review is constantly updated to reflect this data, and we also test new wipers as they become available.

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose Windshield Wipers

While they might more often be a last-second add-on to your oil change, wiper blades can be pretty important when you need them. We’ve tried our best to find mid-stream substitutes (note: your buddy leaning out the window furiously wiping won’t cut it), but it’s best to get dialed in before you need them. Like ensuring your headlights are clear or looking into that pesky engine code, taking care of your wipers will pay dividends in keeping your ride on the road for longer.

Our testing revealed that there’s actually a good bit of tech baked into these simple accessories, and things like wiper design, blade compound, and wipe-on coatings can greatly improve performance and durability over the lifespan of your wipers. Consider the following before you replace your next set to ensure you’re getting the best wiper for the money.

Windshield Wiper Blade Design

Windshield wiper blades haven’t changed much since their invention (credit one Mary Anderson, 1903, by the way) but there are a few key ways we’ve been able to squeeze more squeegee performance out of them. One of those is in the overall blade frame design.

Traditional Branch Frames

These are the wipers that have been used on vehicles for years. They are simple in design and accommodate the curve in modern windshields, but don’t provide much force in clinging tightly to the glass. Most often made of painted or powder-coated steel, heavy use will wear these frames and can eventually rust. 

In areas of heavy snow and ice, branch-style wipers can become inundated with ice build-up between the branch elements, causing the blades to chatter as they fail to glide across the windshield. For drivers in drier climates, branch wipers like the SilBlade Standards or PIAA Super Silicones can be an economical choice. Because they aren’t as essential, we run branch-style wipers on all of our rear window wiper blades.

Beam Frames

Modern wiper blades use a beam frame design, which is often a one- or two-piece design with metal bands to provide even pressure across the length of the wiper beam. Because there are no pressure points, beam-style wipers are often higher quality than branch-style offerings, with less chatter and hang-ups.

Beam-style wipers also cling tighter to the windshield, making them more aerodynamic and lessening wind noise and lift. In our testing, the Bosch Icons just about have the style perfected, and exhibit great flex and contact.

Hybrid Frames

Hybrid-designed frames combine a bit of both styles of wiper blades and incorporate an aerodynamic cover to a branch frame to lessen wind-lifting and keep your wipers where they need to be. This also helps eliminate the icing issue that comes with many branch frames.

Performance

Quantifying wiper performance might seem a bit in the weeds, but we wanted to really split hairs in finding the best wipers, so we put together a quasi-scientific test. Armed with our trusted garden hose and a ladder, we simulated a classic Pacific Northwest spring day, complete with every type of rain you could imagine (sprinkles to deluge), and recorded our findings to dissect later.

The primary wipe is the one that removes most of the water from your windshield. During this stroke, we looked for a clean motion with no shuddering or streaking, and we audio recorded to compare the relative sound produced by each blade. In lesser blades, the ends of the blades are where we noticed hang-ups occurring the most, and this is also where the most streaking was introduced.

During the pause in between wipes, we could tell which blades were removing the most water by just how clear the windshield was in the brief time before more water hit it. As a broad observation, beam-style wipers had better contact across the entire surface of the windshield, removing water more evenly than branch-style frames.

Silicone wipers, too, made a noticeable difference, with only a few wipes necessary before the silicone began transferring to the glass and beading water. This aided in removing water in between wipes — meaning a lower wiper speed could be used.

Wiper Compounds

Your wiper or squeegee element is where the rubber meets the road — er, windshield. These thin strips of rubber or silicone are shaped to end at a point and adapt to the curvature of your window, squeezing the water from beneath it and shuttling it away.

Rubber Blades

The prevailing wiper material for many years, natural rubber is still used heavily in wiper blades and provides a high-quality wipe when maintained well. Dirty windshields are the number one cause of poor-performing wiper blades and can gum up and damage rubber wipers until they no longer wipe properly.

Rubber blades do have a functional lifespan, as they are susceptible to damage from the sun’s UV rays, the ozone in the atmosphere, and high temperatures.

Silicone Blades

Silicone wipers, while often more expensive, do offer a number of advantages over rubber wipers, including better resistance to the environmental elements that degrade them. These types of wipers also offer the added benefit of depositing a thin layer of silicone with every wipe, which adds that water-repellant finish we’re big fans of.

Wipers like the Rain-X Silicone Endura or PIAA Si-Tech easily outperformed the rubber wipers in our tests, and seemingly only get better with additional use as they bed in that silicone layer.

Coated Blades

While they can be either rubber or silicone, many manufacturers add coatings to their wiper elements, such as Teflon or graphite, in order to decrease friction. Know that these treatments won’t last forever, but will increase performance and make your wipers work less, meaning they’ll last longer.

The graphite coating on the Rain-X Latitudes assuredly helps make them one of the quietest wipers in our review, and the ceramic coating on the Trico Silicone Ceramics is a high-tech layer that reduces friction for easier wiping.

Wiper Blade Mounting

While the prevailing wiper attachment is going to be the J-hook style, there are many other styles used on vehicles today, with some of the more common being side pins, bayonets, and push button mounts. 

Because wiper blades need to be used on many different vehicles, they often integrate a number of different adapters into a single mount. Because the universe of wiper attachments can be dizzying, it’s best to consult an auto parts store or online resource to ensure the wipers you’re purchasing are compatible with your vehicle. 

It’s also important to note that there are ‘exact fit’ wiper blades available today, which are specified to meet the OE, or original equipment, requirements of your vehicle manufacturer. These blades won’t be fitted with any adapters, and instead only fit your vehicle, making the process a simpler affair.

Durability and When to Replace

Even the best wiper blades will eventually need replacing, but investing in a set that’ll go the distance can push off that date by a long time. 

Most wiper blades will begin to degrade in performance around the 6-month mark, with many needing replacement after a year. However, with more high-end wiper blades, we have successfully run the same set for upward of 2 years with little loss in ability.

The most durable wiper blades will likely be beam-style designs, which have fewer moving parts and are less likely to become inundated with debris and ice. Silicone wipers also last much longer than their natural rubber counterparts due to their more stable chemical composition. 

Using an off-the-shelf water-repellant treatment such as Rain-X can significantly improve the performance of your wiper blades. The coating causes water to bead and roll off your windshield, meaning you can avoid using your wipers altogether in light mist. Cleaning your wipers regularly will also prolong their life and keep debris from tearing the wiper elements.

Consider replacing your wipers once they begin to leave streaks on your windshield, or making any sort of chattering or squeaking sounds.

FAQ